Hello Internet!!!!
Today I'm reviewing most of the liquid liners that has made it in my collection!!
I'm going to do short reviews of each and a smudge test here we go lets do it
Here are the eyeliners that made it in my collection
Left to Right:
- Loreal Telescopic Liquid Eyeliner
-NYX Matte Liquid LIner
- ELF Intense Ink Liner
- MACQUEEN Liquid Liner
- ULTA Precise Liquid LIner
- CATRICE Waterproof LIquid Liner
- Jesse's Girl Liquid Liner
Loreal Telescopic Liner:
Consistency is very watery and pigment is not really there even when I shake the bottle, which is quite disappointing because this is the most expensive liner in this post
- Straight up just crayola marker dipped in water idk theres not much to say about this I'm not even sure why its in my collection
- the brush is a very stiff felt tip which does not bend at all so imagine the eraser end of a pencil
- very hard to make wing with this because the tip doesn't bend
NYX Matte liquid Liner
- Consistency is nice and thick, very pigmented in color but doesn't sink into skin, rather it lies on top and crumbles off when you remove it
- brush tip but the brush isn't pointy so precise wing is quite hard to achieve
- VERY BLACK, probably the most pigmented out of all of these
ELF Intense Black Liner
-Pointy Felt tip with pretty good pigmentation, doesn't sit on the skin but sinks in so it doesn't crumble off your feace
- not waterproof (doesn't claim to be but is terribel on the lashline because it transfers immediately with contect with water)
- The felt wears off after a few uses
-affordable
MACQUEEN LIquid LIner
- Korean Brand that is sold on Yesstyle for about 5$
- Brush tip, waterproof, pigmented
-perfect for the lasline and for a precise wing
- VERY VERY comparable to the Stila Liquid LIner and Kat Von D
- Doesn't run or crumble
-Long lasting on oily Lids
- My favorite eyeliner ev e r
Ulta Precision Liquid Liner
- Very Thin so its perfect for creating a wing
- Felt Tip but the fibers from the felt comes off after like every use
-EXTREMEMLY pigmented so perfect for the perfect dark wing
- perfect on the lashliner and waterline even though it doesn't say its waterproof
- Lays on the skin so it crumbles off but only when you try to remove it
-doesnt run throughout the day
Catrice Waterproof Liquid Liner
- Pointy Felt tip which is perefect for a wing but lacking pigmemtation, almost as bad as the Loreal one
-Crumbles off skin throughout the day
-So pointy that you can't'really apply it on the waterline
Jesse's Girl Liquid Liner
- Pigmented and stays on the skin (doesn not crumble) more of an eyeliner stain that sinks into the skin
- Precise Brush Tip, perfect for a wing but less precise than the Macqueen liner
- 2nd place, will always repurchase
NEXT IS THE SMUDGE TEST
I only rubbed the right side of the swatches with a Wet Wipe and from the worst to best is
Loreal Telescopic
Elf Intense LL
Jesse's Girl
Catrice
Macqueen
NYX
NEXT IS THE FINGER SMUDGE TEST (left side of swatches)
Only ones that smudged is the ELF one
FINALLY THE MICELLAR WATER TEST
1) the first photo, I swiped it once
2) I swiped it a few more times
3) I swiped until the majority of it was cleaned off
(winners are the MACQUEEN Liquid Liner (5$) and the Jesse's Girl Liner (7$), both comparable to the Stila Liquid Eyeliner and the KVD Liquid Liner but 10x cheaper and I love it)
(update 4/4/18: macqueen eyeliner is still on my wrist and it'll come off if i use makeup remover but with water and soap it wont budge im shook)
